I personally played the Wii version (Yes I know it lacked some things from the PS2 version, but I lack a PS2 or PS3 so...) and it is by far my favorite game. When you can have a game spoiled for you and it still turns out fantastic, you know its good. I did, however, show the HD trailer to one of my art teachers and she really liked it and I got to write a little bit about for an assignment.
Overall, its an amazing story, with amazing art, and amazing gameplay. Not to say it does not have it flaws but really, what game dosent?