I prefer games such such as the Last of Us, Nether, Gmod Slender; multiplayer (A LOT scarier then the original game) DayZ,... Outlast, amnesia, penumbra, etc. I prefer games where you get more of a feeling of being the hunted, not just jumpscare.
I mean when I first started playing it it was horrifying, but after a while (Several days) The jump scares got somewhat predictable.