I, myself, am actually quite fond of these:
Smiledog = <33
Ben Drowned = At first I wasn't able to sleep at night xD, but after a while I began to gain on this creepypasta and fell in love with it
Happiness For Sale = <3333 8D Sorry, I've always loved the happy mask salesman and thought there was something scary about him and I found 'm on creepypasta. xD I love ya, Happy!
Jeff The Killer = 'Tis alright for me, not a favorite.
Not saying I don't like him, just not a favvie.
Err, pretty much it. xD