Whovian Debate-Best New Doctor?

[papayatoot]

I've been wanting to debate about this for some time, but I can't find any IRL fans XD

My question is, which of the "new-age" (9-12) Doctors is the best? I think it's Capaldi. Please share your thoughts below!

[hugrf2]

Yayyyyy a place for my people 8D

But both Matt Smith and David Tennent (Forgot how to spell his last name...?) are my favorites. 10 used to be my number 1 favorite, actually, although now I look back on the flaws and interestingness of both styles of episodes of the two, I'm having a harder time deciding.

To be honest, I'm not really liking Capaldi /too/ much... I haven't watched DW in a while I guess, but of course I'll give him a chance, just not liking him that much so far.

[Hooli]

I really, really like Capaldi. Though Smith has to be my favorite regeneration. c: I also really love Tennant, and Eccleston.. I loved all of them okay? ;; It's really hard to choose but yeah, Smith / 11 is my favorite doctor.

[Jango_Fett]

Nine brought this series back from the dead.

Ten cemented it and made sure it stayed.

Eleven kept everyone entertained and invested.

Twelve sadly had to take a back-seat to his companion, but now he's bringing some seriously good fun back.


therefore all of them win.

[papayatoot]

12 has made me feel just as many feels as 10 did, but 12 doesn't have the sex appeal like the others did. I like Capaldi because he shows how old the doctor really is. 9 has to be my least favorite, I don't really know why.

But I think we can all agree that Mickey was the worst

[Jango_Fett]

12 has made me feel just as many feels as 10 did, but 12 doesn't have the sex appeal like the others did. I like Capaldi because he shows how old the doctor really is. 9 has to be my least favorite, I don't really know why.

But I think we can all agree that Mickey was the worst

martha took the worst companion slot for me

that or clara

[hugrf2]

12 has made me feel just as many feels as 10 did, but 12 doesn't have the sex appeal like the others did. I like Capaldi because he shows how old the doctor really is. 9 has to be my least favorite, I don't really know why.

But I think we can all agree that Mickey was the worst

martha took the worst companion slot for me

that or clara

Yeah, I don't really think I liked Martha as much...

Donna, though, is my favorite companion, which makes me like the Tenth Doctor seasons even more now... <_< But her "end" was really sad...

[papayatoot]

really? omg I loved clara, she and donna were the less follow-y followers (if you know what I mean). Clara has to be my favorite. at least martha slayed racism in that one episode

[G4RG0YLE]

Capaldi isn't quite as good as Matt Smith or David Tennant, no way.
BUT I do like the fact that he gives it a good try and the series he's been in so far are going well. Think he can be a bit more dramatic though like Smithy and Tennant, they were always acting like such comedians!
Lovin' it so far though. Wonder who'll be our next Doctor?
What about Sarah Jane Smith?! She was an amazing companion! HOW DARE YOU ALL NOT MENTION HER AMAZINGNESS! K-9 GUYS! C'MON D8!

[papayatoot]

yes female doctor female doctor female doctor
wait
female GINGER doctor
yesyesyes

I think the reason a lot of people have a hard time liking Capaldi is because he's not as playful and naiive as the other doctors were; he's the meaner, more vengeful side of the doctor that hasn't gotten to come into play but now it is because we get to see how broken the Doctor really is. I like to see them all as layers of his personality and we get to delve deeper with every new actor.