Wow... I never thought something as stupid as this would happen ._. I just started taking preset requests myself and am now doubting if they will be used to good use...
And the warrior cat hopping is ridiculous.... Sure, I have a few warriors my self, heck i have an entire made up clan, but i dont ask for 19ish presets for each one of them... Also, most cat species are the same so can't the creator just say the preset is going to be public so other users can be the same breed? It would mean less downloading and waiting for everyone in the end...
I keep an archive of preset downloads private because i honestly really like some of the ones i've done. I want to say now if I know one of the ones I made is going unused to post it public. Like Suga said, we put work, hours and maybe even love (heheh i know cheesy but it happens) into presets. To discard our artwork like that would hurt anyone's feeling, let alone how can they have the guts to ask you to make another one???
Sorry for ranting so much but the thought of this really does sadden me... :,(