I appreciate that you tried to help, but it turned out to be my own derpy fail in the end... XD
After I posted this, I told my mate about it to see if HE saw the same thing, which he did, so we sat there for about 30 minutes pondering on what it could be.
I tried your method, Ingredient, but sadly, it didn't work, so I put it in a new category to see if THAT helped. Well no... nothing XD
Finally my mate goes wandering around and says, "Hey, is the weather on? Maybe that's it owo"
He didn't actually think that was the issue, but he said it reminded him of how snow acts, which was totally true. So I go back into map maker and low-and-behold, I have "Eternal Snow" set as the weather cycle >.<
Originally I had planned making the garden open where you could see the moon and such, but in the end I decided using another .sky file would be too much of a hassle so I just added a ceiling and made it pitch black so it didn't seem like there was one.
So thankfully, my mate figured this one out XD <3