You want me to explain why I like Scourge?
First of all, a lot of people want to be contrary and like the 'bad guy,' but that's not the reason for me.
I like how powerful he is, but he still is caring on the inside, he's just power-hungry now. He still cares for BloodClan and wants the best for his own Clan, though, because of the pain in his path he took the wrong road and was killed for it-I feel empathy for him and all he had to go through, and how he used that pain to become strong. Also, I never really like Firestar, I don't like protagonists most of the time-the only protagonist I like is Naruto, but only because he doesn't seem like someone who would be a protagonist and isn't such a 'great hero' like Firestar or Percy Jackson or Harry Potter.
Off-topic, but, in a nutshell, that's why I like Scourge. It's okay if you don't agree with my motives, but that's just why I like him C: Not saying that's why everyone likes him either.